Buffalo Faces Rising College Costs Amid Loan Restart
Author: Jack Haxton
The college experience has long been viewed as a rite of passage—valued by families, employers, and society as a key step toward financial and professional stability. But that perception is starting to shift. Increasing financial pressures, emerging alternatives to traditional degrees, and evolving views on the return on investment (ROI) of higher education are all contributing to a national—and local—decline in college enrollment. With federal student loan collections set to resume in May 2025, the question of whether a degree is worth the debt is once again front and center.
The Rising Cost of Higher Education
Since the early 2000s, college tuition across Western New York has risen dramatically, with many institutions seeing increases in the 60% to 110% range. In-state and out-of-state students alike have seen steep hikes in the cost of admission, contributing to the growing concern around affordability.
These tuition increases are not isolated to a single school—they reflect a broader trend affecting public and private colleges in the Buffalo area and beyond. Over the last two decades, attending a four-year institution has become significantly more expensive, with local tuition increases outpacing inflation and wage growth.
The Weight of Student Debt
Graduates from local colleges can expect to leave school with student loan balances ranging from $24,000 to $28,000, on average. With interest rates around 6%, monthly payments can take up a significant portion—roughly 7–8%—of a graduate’s starting salary, estimated at around $56,000 annually.
For many, this is not just a number on paper—it’s a decade-long financial commitment. As the repayment pause ends in May, thousands of recent graduates in the region will resume payments, making tough financial choices in the process. This reality has many prospective students reconsidering whether a traditional college path is worth the long-term financial impact.
Declining Enrollment and Shifting Career Paths
The nationwide enrollment decline is mirrored in the Buffalo region, where local colleges have experienced undergraduate population drops ranging from 8% to nearly 18% between 2020 and 2023. These decreases reflect a growing hesitation among young people to assume large amounts of debt for a degree that may not offer immediate or direct career benefits.
Although higher education still provides advantages—such as improved job prospects—those benefits are not guaranteed. Roughly 48% of recent graduates find employment in their field of study, while 52% work in roles that don’t require a college degree. Alarmingly, 45% of underemployed graduates remain so, even 10 years post-graduation.
Despite these numbers, some institutions continue to report high job placement rates and competitive starting salaries. However, these successes don’t always reflect the broader student experience, especially when long-term career alignment and debt payoff are taken into account.
A Dream in Question
As student loan collections resume, more families are exploring alternative, debt-free career paths—including trade schools and certificate programs. Whether the college model can adapt to these economic and cultural shifts remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the decision to pursue higher education is more complex—and consequential—than ever.
Thinking about college or a career path?
Start planning your finances now to avoid long-term debt and set yourself up for financial freedom. Learn more about college planning, contact us today!
